I heard a
This American Life in which David Rakoff mentions a statistic that says that people who watch a television show with a continuing storyline and characters who grow and develop, something like The Office, reap the same benefits from the television program that actually spending time with real live human beings gives them. Mr. Rakoff then mentions that he doesn't watch TV because unlike real people television can't look over at him and check whether or not he's died on the couch.
I listen to about 4-6 hours of podcasts every workday. I would argue that this behavior is much more damaging than watching an episode or two of The Office and becoming sort of involved in how Jim and Pam are doing. Podcasts are sneakier, because the production values tend towards the amateur. It is a lot like tapping the phone conversations of two people you happen to think are funny. Much like a phone conversation, you only remember the interesting things the other person said as material for good story fodder later. Unlike a phone conversation, they do not know you are there.
Podcasts that make me feel this way:
-Jordan Jesse Go
-You Look Nice Today
-Stephen Fry's Podgrams
-The Bitterest Pill
In some ways this is even more pathetic than WoW because in WoW I've heard that you make and play with friends who know that you are on the other side of the DancingOrcBearThing they are running around a giant fantasy land with. Instead, not knowing that you are sitting trapped in an office in Long Island City thinking to yourself, "Man, if these guys knew me they'd totally be friends with me." Although I have to say realistically probably the only people on these podcasts I'd want to be friends with would be Jordan Morris and Stephen Fry.
*Other podcasts I listen to that are quality, but not a two guys chatting show:
The Bugle - really funny news entertainment show
The Moth - live storytelling in NY
New Yorker: Fiction - someone reads a new yorker story outloud and then discusses it
The Sound of Young America - Jesse Thorn, an obnoxious host who eventually grows on you interviews really interesting people
This American Life - duh
Science Talk - the podcast of Scientific American
Downloadable Content: The Penny Arcade Podcast - this almost could have been a two guys chatting about video games bu they do actually make something by the end of it